A surfer paddling out at an Indonesian reef break (photo: Salt Atlas, Rote Island)

Journal · Surf & travel guides · Mentawai Islands

Mentawai surf for intermediates

The short answer: yes, the Mentawai Islands work for intermediates, if you pick the right base and the right months. Stay somewhere with softer waves within a short boat ride, such as Mini Macas at Macaronis or Pitstops in the Playgrounds, and consider November to February, when the surf is smaller.

Best months
November to FebruarySmaller, quieter surf
Also good
March and OctoberShoulder season
Choose
A land stayNot a charter
Bring
Reef bootiesEvery wave here is reef

Are you ready?

A quick self-check

Most Mentawai waves break over shallow coral, and the famous ones are fast and hollow. You don’t need to be an expert, but you’ll get far more out of a trip if you can tick these off.

  • You paddle into green, unbroken waves on your own
  • You can angle your take-off and ride along the face, left and right
  • You can duck-dive or turtle-roll through head-high whitewater
  • You’re comfortable in a line-up and know the right of way
  • You can stay calm if you fall and hit the bottom: cover your head, don’t stand up on the reef

If that’s you, you’re an intermediate the Mentawai Islands can work for. If not, a sandier coast first, such as Sri Lanka’s south coast, will move you on faster.

The waves to aim for

Intermediate-friendly Mentawai waves

These are the waves the stays themselves point intermediates to. Times are by boat from the stay named.

WaveNearWhat it’s like
Mini MacasMacaronis Resort, 5 minA mellow left inside the main break, best at high tide and usually empty.
Silabu LeftMacaronis ResortA confidence-building left that stays offshore when the wind turns south. All tides.
Macas RightMacaronis ResortA long-walled right, often quiet. Mid to high tide.
PitstopsMentawai Surf Retreat, out frontReef onto sand, all tides, works on small swells.
Beng BengsMentawai Surf Retreat, 8 minA fast, rippable left in a quiet bay; better at low tide.
NipussiMentawai Surf Retreat, 12 minA consistent right on small and medium swells, low to mid tide.
Good TimesDriftwood Mentawai, 10 minA mellow take-off and long walls.
BintangsKingfisher Resort, 5 minA short right, fun and rippable when it’s small.
TikusSolid Surf HouseA fun left over clear water for beginners, intermediates and longboarders.

The headline waves, such as Macaronis itself, Rifles, HT’s and Bank Vaults, are for when you’re surfing well and the size is right. Your guide will tell you.

When to go

Timing matters more than anywhere

MonthsFor an intermediate
November to FebruaryBest fit. The wet season: smaller surf, fewer people.
March and OctoberGood, at a stay with softer waves nearby.
April to SeptemberPeak swell. Doable at the right stay, but the famous reefs are at their heaviest.

Month-by-month detail is in Mentawai surf season: month by month.

Land, not boat

Charters chase the best-known waves and the boats we list are built for intermediate and advanced crews. A land stay keeps the softer waves within a short ride and gives you more choice day to day. More in Mentawai boat trip vs land camp.

FAQ

Common questions

Is the Mentawai Islands too advanced for intermediates?

Not if you choose well. The famous reefs are heavy, but stays like Macaronis Resort, Mentawai Surf Retreat and Kingfisher have softer waves close by, and the wet season, November to February, is smaller.

What is the best Mentawai resort for intermediates?

Look for gentler waves within a short boat ride. Macaronis Resort points intermediates to Mini Macas, Silabu Left and Macas Right; Mentawai Surf Retreat has Pitstops out front and Beng Bengs and Nipussi nearby.

When should an intermediate go to the Mentawai Islands?

November to February is the best fit: the wet season, with smaller surf. March and October work well too.

Do I need reef booties?

They’re worth packing. Every wave here breaks over reef, and booties make getting in and out much easier.

Will there be a guide in the water?

Many stays include local surf guides who pick the wave for your level and the conditions. Ask us which ones do.

Sources

Written by Salt Atlas. Checked November 2026. Facts were taken from these first-hand public sources:

  • Waves, levels and boat times: the surf guides published by Macaronis Resort, Mentawai Surf Retreat, Driftwood Mentawai, Kingfisher Resort and Solid Surf House, summarised on their Salt Atlas pages.
  • Seasons: Surfline guides for Macaronis and Kandui.

This guide is general information to help you plan. Reef surfing carries real risk; always surf within your ability and follow your guide.

Newsletter

First look at new expeditions

Sign up for the latest departures and get early access before trips sell out. Small groups fill fast.

We'll email you about new departures and offers. Unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.

Partners & memberships