
Journal · Surf & travel guides · Mentawai Islands
Mentawai boat trip vs land camp
The short answer: choose a charter boat if you’re an intermediate-to-advanced crew who wants to chase the swell between island groups and can fill a boat. Choose a land camp or resort if you want a room ashore, a mix of levels, flexible dates, or a wave you can paddle out to.
- Boat
- Follows the swellFixed dates, whole boat
- Land
- Surfs its own zoneFlexible dates, a room ashore
- Guests
- 8 to 12 on most boatsMany camps take 12 or fewer
- Both
- Fly into Padang (PDG)Plus the Mentawai surf tax
Side by side
How they compare
| Charter boat | Land camp or resort | |
|---|---|---|
| Waves | Moves between island groups to match swell and wind, including remote reefs | The reefs within boat range of your island, sometimes a wave out front |
| Level | Intermediate and advanced: the charters we list name no progression waves | Wider. Some stays have softer waves and lessons alongside the reefs |
| Dates | Fixed departures, often 10 to 12 days | More flexible, though some run set check-in days |
| Group | Usually booked as a whole boat for 8 to 12 guests | Book a room; you share the island with other guests |
| Living | A cabin for the whole trip | A room or bungalow, with more space between sessions |
| Getting there | Sails from Padang, often overnight, so you wake at the first break | Usually a night in Padang, then a ferry or speedboat crossing |
| Flat days | The boat moves to find surf | Fishing, snorkelling and the resort itself |
Charter boat
Choose a boat if…
- You’re all confident on reef. Charters head for the best-known waves, and the boats we list are built for intermediate and advanced surfers.
- You can fill it. Most boats take 8 to 12 guests and are best value as a whole boat. MV Addiction takes 8; Star Koat II and Siloina take up to 12.
- You want range. A boat can run from the Mentawai Islands to the Telos, and some routes reach Nias and the Banyaks when the swell allows.
- You’d rather skip Padang. Several charters meet you at the airport and sail the same day, as long as you land by the time they set.
Land camp or resort
Choose land if…
- Your group mixes levels. Macaronis Resort has a beginner wave over sand, Fish Fingers, as well as its famous left, and Solid Surf House has Tikus for beginners and longboarders.
- You want a wave out front. At Mentawai Surf Retreat, Pitstops is about thirty steps away; at Driftwood you can paddle to E-Bay.
- You want more than surf. A room ashore, space on rest days, and snorkelling, kayaks or fishing at some stays.
- Your dates are fixed by work. Land stays offer more start dates than boats, though some, like Macaronis, check in on set days.
Before you compare prices
What to check in any quote
- Is the Padang transfer included, and is there a night in Padang to pay for?
- Is the crossing included (ferry or speedboat), or extra?
- Are boat trips to the breaks unlimited, or charged by the trip?
- Is the Mentawai surf tax included? Everyone surfing there pays it.
- Is medical evacuation cover required? Some stays make it compulsory.
Partner prices are on request because they depend on your dates, room and group. Ask us and we’ll set out what is and isn’t included.
FAQ
Common questions
Is a Mentawai boat trip better than a resort?
Not better, different. A boat reaches more waves when the swell moves around; a resort gives you a room ashore, flexible dates and, at some stays, waves for mixed levels. For a crew of confident surfers who can fill a boat, a charter is hard to beat.
Can beginners go on a Mentawai charter?
We wouldn’t recommend it. The charters we list are built for intermediate and advanced surfers and name no progression waves. A land stay with a beginner wave is the better choice.
How many people go on a Mentawai charter?
Usually 8 to 12 guests, and most are booked as a whole boat.
Do I need a night in Padang?
For most land stays, yes: you stay in Padang before the morning ferry or speedboat. Charters often sail the day you land, as long as your flight arrives in time.
Which is better in the wet season?
November to February is smaller and quieter, and fewer boats run. A land stay with softer waves usually suits that time of year better. See Mentawai surf season: month by month.
Surf the Mentawai Islands
Boats and stays we work with
Charter boats
- MV AddictionFrom Padang8 guests · whole boat
- Tengirri Surf ChartersMentawai and Telos8 guests at most
- Star Koat IIMentawai Islands12 guests at most
- Siloina Surf ChartersMentawai, Telos, Nias and Banyaks12 guests at most
Land camps and resorts
Sources
Written by Salt Atlas. Checked November 2026. Facts were taken from these first-hand public sources:
- Boat sizes, routes, departure times and inclusions: each charter operator’s own published information (MV Addiction, Tengirri, Star Koat II, Siloina), summarised on its Salt Atlas page.
- Stays, waves and transfers: each resort’s own published information (Macaronis Resort, Mentawai Surf Retreat, Driftwood Mentawai, Solid Surf House), summarised on its Salt Atlas page.
- Surf tax: Macaronis Resort’s summary of Mentawai surf-tourism rules, which links the Mentawai Islands Regency’s own decrees.
This guide is general information to help you plan. Boats, dates and inclusions change; we confirm the details for your dates in your quote.






